data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a793/5a79329263bfeb727ca680ccf6a19570a5a81f00" alt="Marketer showing SEO concept,optimization analysis tools, search engine rankings, social media sites based on results analysis data,Website Search Optimization ,Interesting web rankings from visitors"
The New SEO Playbook: Writing for Both AI and Humans in 2025
Feb 21, 2025 6.5 minutes
AI has transformed how we approach SEO, creating a dual audience we need to target – machines and humans. Let’s explore how to balance these competing needs while maximizing your visibility with an AI SEO strategy.
SECURE YOUR BUSINESS FROM FRAUD
Understanding AI-First Search
Today’s search engines are incredibly sophisticated, using AI that thinks and understands content almost like a human would. Gone are the days when stuffing keywords into your content would get you to the top of search results.
How AI “Reads”
Think of modern search AI as a really smart reader who’s going through your content, understanding not just the words you’re using, but how ideas connect and flow together. These AI systems are looking at your content from every angle, trying to figure out if you’re really providing value or just playing the SEO game.
What’s fascinating is how these AI systems work behind the scenes. They’re constantly learning from billions of searches, understanding patterns, and figuring out what makes content truly valuable. This is what’s called topic relationship matching.
When someone types in a search query, the AI isn’t just matching keywords – it’s trying to understand what the person really wants to know and find the best possible answer.
This is how natural language processing works. Through semantic search understanding, AI can predict user intent. Through that prediction, “valuable” content is provided.
How AI Evaluates
The way AI evaluates your content is pretty incredible. It’s looking at how thoroughly you cover a topic, checking if you’re using natural language patterns, and even assessing whether you’re a credible source in your field.
It’s like having a super-smart editor who can instantly tell if you know what you’re talking about or if you’re just repeating what everyone else has said. You need to have a genuine, unique idea. Otherwise, both AI and potential customers will think you’re just another cog spinning the same old machine.
You need to show genuine expertise in your content. This means diving deep into topics, explaining complex ideas in simple terms, and connecting different concepts in ways that make sense.
The AI is smart enough to tell when you’re just skimming the surface versus when you’re providing real insight. Don’t focus so much on content breadth as much as depth.
E-E-A-T in an AI World
While AI is driving how content gets discovered, you can’t forget about your human readers. The best approach is to create content that’s comprehensive enough to satisfy AI’s need for depth while keeping it engaging and readable for real people.
Think of it as writing for two audiences simultaneously. The AI that will help people find your content, and the humans who will actually read and act on it.
Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness all need to push through every piece you publish so humans—potential customers—know exactly why they should buy from you.
If you’re genuinely knowledgeable about your topic and can communicate clearly, you’re already halfway there. Share real experiences, back up your claims with data, and maintain a consistent publishing presence that shows you’re a reliable voice in your field.
At the end of the day, AI is just the messenger. It’s getting smarter at connecting your content with the right audience, but it’s your human readers who will ultimately decide if your content is worth their time and trust.
PREPARE YOUR BUSINESS FOR MORE VOLUME
Writing Content for AI Systems
Let’s talk about how to write content that AI absolutely loves, while keeping it natural and engaging. The trick isn’t to stuff your content with keywords or follow some rigid formula. Instead, be thorough and organized in a way that makes sense.
Think of AI as your most detail-oriented reader. It’s scanning your content, trying to understand how well you explain concepts and how everything fits together. The better you organize your information, the more likely AI will see your content as valuable and share it with the right audience.
The Power of Structure
Structure not only makes your content look pretty, but it also easy to understand. When you break down complex topics into clear sections with descriptive headings, you’re creating a roadmap that helps AI understand your content’s flow.
Use H2s and H3s strategically, but don’t go overboard. Nobody likes a document that looks like a table of contents exploded.
Getting Semantic
Modern AI understands concepts and relationships better than you expect, avoiding the need for exact keyword matches. When you’re writing about a topic, think about all the related ideas and questions your readers might have.
For example, if you’re writing about coffee brewing, don’t just stick to the basic steps. Talk about water temperature, bean selection, grinding techniques, and how these elements work together to create the perfect cup.
The Entity Connection
AI loves it when you connect related concepts naturally. Instead of just mentioning a term, explain how it relates to your main topic.
Let’s say you’re writing about digital marketing – don’t just list tactics. Explain how email marketing connects to social media strategy, or how content marketing supports SEO efforts. These connections help AI understand the broader context of your content.
Question-Answer Format
One of the most effective ways to get AI’s attention is to answer specific questions your audience is asking. But don’t just drop random Q&As into your content. Weave them naturally into your narrative.
Address common concerns, tackle misconceptions, and provide clear solutions to real problems. This approach not only helps with featured snippets but also shows AI that you’re providing genuine value.
Technical Details Matter
While you’re focusing on creating natural, flowing content, don’t forget about the technical stuff. Use schema markup where it makes sense. Keep your URLs clean and descriptive. Make sure your images have alt text that actually describes what they show.
These technical elements help AI understand every aspect of your content.
Freshness and Updates
AI systems love fresh content, but that doesn’t mean you need to publish something new every day. Instead, regularly update your existing content with new information, examples, or insights.
This shows AI that you’re actively maintaining and improving your content, which can give you an edge in search results.
Writing for AI isn’t about gaming the system – it’s about being thorough, clear, and helpful. When you create content that’s well-structured and comprehensive, you’re not just making AI happy; you’re creating something that’s genuinely valuable for your human readers too.
This approach tends to rank well naturally because you’re actually providing what both AI and humans are looking for: quality information presented in an accessible way.
Creating a Hybrid Strategy
You can’t just write for AI and expect your business to thrive. At the same time, you can’t ignore AI if you want your content to be found. Creating a balanced strategy that serves both masters effectively is the solution you’re after.
The Art of Content Segmentation
Think of your content like a well-balanced investment portfolio. You need different types of content for different purposes.
Some of your content should be specifically crafted to capture AI attention and dominate search results. This might be your comprehensive guides, your how-to articles, or your in-depth explanations of complex topics. These pieces serve as your visibility engines, pulling in traffic from search results.
Many businesses go wrong when they try to make every piece of content AI-optimized. Don’t fall into this trap. Some of your content needs to focus purely on connecting with humans, telling your brand story, and converting visitors into customers. These might be your case studies, your sales pages, or your email newsletters.
The 60/40 Rule
Here’s a practical approach I’ve seen work well: Aim for about 60% of your content to be optimized for both AI and humans, while keeping 40% focused primarily on human engagement and conversion.
This ratio gives you enough SEO-friendly content to maintain strong search visibility while ensuring you have plenty of high-conversion content for your human visitors.
Content Mapping
Start by mapping out your customer journey. Where do people first discover you? What information do they need at each stage? This mapping helps you decide which content pieces need heavy AI optimization and which ones should focus more on human connection.
For example, your top-of-funnel content – the stuff people find when they’re first researching a problem – should be heavily optimized for AI discovery. But your bottom-of-funnel content – the pieces that convince people to buy – should prioritize human connection and emotional resonance.
Practical Implementation
Let’s break this down into actionable steps:
For AI-Optimized Content:
- Create comprehensive resource pages
- Develop detailed how-to guides
- Write thorough FAQ sections
- Build topic clusters around your main services
For Human-Focused Content:
- Craft compelling story-driven case studies
- Design conversion-focused landing pages
- Write engaging email sequences
- Create persuasive sales copy
Measuring What Matters
The beauty of this hybrid approach is that you can track both visibility and engagement metrics. Watch how your AI-optimized content performs in search rankings and featured snippets. Also keep a close eye on conversion rates and engagement metrics for your human-focused content.
The Update Strategy
Regularly audit your content performance. Sometimes, a piece you designed for AI optimization might actually connect really well with humans. When this happens, consider creating two versions – keep the AI-optimized version for search, but create a more conversational version for your email subscribers or social media followers.
Remember, this isn’t about choosing between AI and humans – it’s about serving both effectively. Your AI-optimized content gets you found, while your human-focused content gets you paid. When you strike the right balance, you create a content ecosystem that not only ranks well but also drives real business results.