Can Shopify Shut Down Your Store? YES! Here’s What to Do

Written by

Your Shopify store is thriving, sales are flowing, and then it hits. That heart-stopping email from Shopify Payments announcing your payment processing has been suspended. I’ve helped hundreds of merchants through this exact situation, and here’s what you need to know: your business isn’t over.

Let me clear up the biggest misconception right away – Shopify hasn’t shut down your store. Your products, your design, your customer access – it’s all still there. The only thing that’s changed is your ability to process payments through Shopify Payments.

Think of it like having multiple doors to your store. Shopify just locked one door (their payment system), but we’ve got several other doors we can open right away. Your customers can still browse your store, add items to cart, and complete purchases. We just need to give them a different way to pay.

KEEP YOUR SHOPIFY STORE UP AND RUNNING

Table of Contents

Why Shopify Suspends Payment Processing

Nobody likes surprises, especially when it comes to your business’s ability to accept payments. As someone who’s helped countless merchants through payment suspensions, I’ll break down exactly why Shopify might hit the pause button on your payment processing.

High-Risk Products

Your payment processing can be suspended if you’re selling products that Shopify considers high-risk. This includes items like CBD products, vape supplies, adult content, firearms, tobacco products, and nutraceuticals.

Even if these products are legal in your area, Shopify maintains strict policies about what can be processed through their payment system.

Transaction Red Flags

Shopify actively monitors for unusual patterns that might indicate trouble. Your payment processing could be suspended if your store shows:

Sudden spikes in order volume that seem unusual
A chargeback rate exceeding 1% of transactions
Multiple refund requests from customers
Late or inconsistent order fulfillment

Verification and Compliance Issues

Sometimes the suspension comes down to paperwork and protocols. Your account might be flagged if there’s:

Insufficient documentation to verify your business identity
Inconsistencies in your business information
Violations of card network rules
Multiple accounts for the same business

The most frustrating part? Sometimes Shopify’s fraud detection system might flag legitimate business activities as suspicious. For instance, a successful marketing campaign that brings a surge of sales could trigger a suspension – even though it’s actually good news for your business.

Here’s what makes this situation less scary: while Shopify might suspend your payment processing, they won’t shut down your entire store. Your products stay listed, your design remains intact, and customers can still browse your catalog. Specifically, the payment processing is affected, and that’s something we can work around with alternative payment solutions.

OPEN A BACKUP PAYMENT SOLUTION

Immediate Action Steps

The moment you receive that suspension notice, time becomes your enemy. I’ve guided numerous merchants through this process, and here’s your exact action plan to keep the revenue flowing.

First: Don’t Panic, Take Action

Your store’s front end remains fully operational, and you’ve got multiple options to continue accepting payments. The key is moving quickly and methodically through these steps.

Review Your Suspension Notice

Take a close look at the email from Shopify. They typically outline specific reasons for the suspension, which helps determine your next moves. Save this email – you’ll need it for reference when setting up alternative payment methods.

NOTE: You more than likely will not be able to reactive your current Shopify Payments account. Don’t spend all your effort pleading with Shopify, focus on the alternatives.

Keep Your Store Running

While you’re sorting out payments, maintain business as usual:

Keep your store online and accessible
Continue marketing efforts
Monitor incoming customer inquiries
Fulfill existing orders promptly
Update your inventory as normal

Customer Communication Strategy

Be proactive but professional with your customers:

Add a temporary banner announcing “Payment System Upgrade in Progress”
Prepare a simple response for customer inquiries about payment issues
Avoid mentioning the suspension – focus on the system upgrade angle

Quick Payment Solutions

Here’s how to get payments flowing again within hours:

Enable PayPal as your immediate backup PSP
Add a “Pay by Square” option for domestic customers
Research high-risk PSPs or payment aggregators
Consider temporary manual invoice solutions for your VIP customers

Document Everything

Start a paper trail of all your actions:

Screenshot your suspension notice
Save all communication with Shopify
Keep records of any affected transactions
Document your timeline of resolution steps

The goal here is maintaining business continuity while you implement more permanent solutions. Remember, this is a common situation in e-commerce, and there’s a clear path forward.

PROTECT YOUR SHOPIFY STORE

Alternative Payment Solutions

When Shopify suspends your payment processing, you’ve got several powerful alternatives to keep your business running smoothly. Here’s your comprehensive guide to the most reliable payment solutions.

PayPal Integration

PayPal stands out as your quickest immediate solution. It’s widely trusted by customers and can be set up on your Shopify store within hours. The integration process is straightforward:

Log into your Shopify dashboard
Navigate to Shopify Payments
Deactivate current settings
Select your PayPal account type
Enter your PayPal credentials

Square as Your PayPal Backup

Square offers a robust alternative to PayPal with several advantages:

Seamless integration with your Shopify store
Ability to process both online and in-person payments
Advanced inventory management tools
Quick deposit times of 1-2 business days
No monthly fees

High-Risk Payment Processors

For long-term stability, open a specialized high-risk payment processor.

Most online businesses don’t know that they are high-risk. Most don’t even know what their Merchant ID (MID) is or their Merchant Category Code (MCC). When signing up with Shopify, you don’t go through the underwriting process. This is why it’s so quick to open an account, because your business hasn’t been looked into.

A real merchant account does the underwriting first. Yes, it takes longer to get your account set up, but it’s much more supportive for longevity. You won’t get shut down for scaling too quickly, selling high-ticket items, or getting a couple chargebacks.

Choosing Your Solution

Your ideal payment setup should include:

A PSP for everyday transactions
A backup processor for redundancy
A primary, specialized high-risk merchant account for long-term stability

Yes, these alternatives might have slightly higher processing fees. However, they provide the stability and security your business needs to continue growing without interruption.