Close-up view on white conceptual keyboard - PayPal (key with logotype)

PayPal Pros and Cons for Merchants

ShareHIDE

Are you considering using PayPal to process payments for your business? Before diving in headfirst, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons carefully before committing to any payment provider.

Let’s cover the pros and cons of PayPal specifically for merchants.

PROCESS PAYMENTS SECURELY TODAY

PayPal Pros for Merchants

1. Quick and Easy Account Setup

PayPal offers one of the quickest and simplest ways to start accepting online payments for your business. You can open a PayPal account and begin processing transactions within just 24 hours in most cases.

This swift setup process stands in stark contrast to the lengthier application and documentation required for a traditional merchant account through a bank. With PayPal, you can bypass the paperwork and start selling almost immediately.

This speedy onboarding is a huge advantage for entrepreneurs eager to launch their online ventures without delay.

2. Widespread Customer Familiarity and Trust

PayPal has built a strong reputation as a trusted and secure payment brand, instilling confidence in millions of online shoppers worldwide. A recent survey reveals that 57% of users trust PayPal for their online purchases, highlighting the platform’s widespread credibility.

By offering PayPal as a payment option on your website, you tap into this reservoir of trust, making potential customers feel more comfortable buying from your business.

Seeing the familiar PayPal logo during checkout can significantly boost your conversion rates. Studies show that consumers are 54% more willing to buy when a business accepts PayPal, especially in unfamiliar situations.

Moreover, 44% of people are more likely to trust and shop with businesses that offer their preferred payment provider upfront. By prominently displaying PayPal as a payment option, you establish trust with potential customers right from the start, encouraging them to proceed with their purchases.

3. Accepts All Major Credit and Debit Cards

PayPal enables you to accept payments from all major credit and debit card brands, including Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. This comprehensive coverage ensures that your customers can pay using their preferred card, making the checkout process seamless and convenient for them.

In addition to credit and debit cards, PayPal also allows customers to pay directly from their bank accounts. This flexibility further expands your potential customer base, as some people prefer using their bank accounts for online transactions.

As all of these bank and card details are stored in PayPal, selecting the preferred method is just a click away for customers. This also guarantees payment for merchants, as PayPal will automatically charge a backup source if the customer’s preferred method doesn’t go through.

5. Supports International Payments

PayPal empowers you to effortlessly accept payments from customers across the globe in various currencies. By leveraging PayPal’s robust international payment capabilities, you can expand your business to new markets without the typical cross-border payment hassles.

With PayPal, you can receive funds from over 200 countries and regions, giving you access to a vast pool of potential customers. The platform automatically handles currency conversions, allowing your international customers to pay in their local currency while you receive the funds in your preferred currency.

This seamless international payment process eliminates the need for you to set up multiple currency accounts or navigate complex foreign exchange procedures.

Moreover, PayPal’s streamlined interface simplifies the management of your international transactions. You can easily view and track payments from different countries within your PayPal account dashboard. This centralized overview saves you time and effort in reconciling your global sales.

START SELLING WITH CONFIDENCE TODAY

PayPal Cons for Merchants

1. Not a Merchant Account

PayPal differs from a traditional merchant account you would obtain through a bank. PayPal operates as an aggregator, which means it pools funds from numerous sellers into a single, shared account. This aggregation model has significant implications for your business.

When you use PayPal, you don’t receive a unique merchant identification number as you would with a dedicated merchant account. This lack of a distinct merchant ID can make it more challenging to establish your business’s individual identity.

Moreover, PayPal’s aggregation approach can lead to account stability issues, particularly if your business experiences rapid growth or unexpected changes in sales volume. If your transaction patterns deviate from what PayPal considers normal, such as a sudden spike in sales or a high volume of transactions, the platform may flag your account for suspicious activity.

In such cases, PayPal may freeze your account and initiate an investigation to ensure the legitimacy of your business practices. This sudden account hold can be highly disruptive, preventing you from accessing your funds and processing new transactions until the review is complete.

The lack of a dedicated merchant account leaves you more vulnerable to these account disruptions.

Furthermore, without a true merchant account, you have limited control over your funds and may face delays in receiving payouts. PayPal retains the right to hold your funds for a certain period or impose rolling reserves, which can strain your cash flow and hinder your ability to reinvest in your business.

2. Can’t Negotiate Fees and Contract Terms

When you sign up for PayPal, you must accept the platform’s standardized fees and contract terms, which apply uniformly to all merchants. Unlike traditional merchant accounts where you can often negotiate rates and tailor your contract to your specific business needs, PayPal offers no such flexibility.

PayPal’s one-size-fits-all approach means you have no room to bargain for lower transaction fees or more favorable terms, regardless of your sales volume or business model.

You’re locked into the same fee structure as every other merchant, which can be particularly disadvantageous if you process a high volume of transactions or operate on tight profit margins.

Moreover, PayPal’s standardized contract includes a broad range of services and features, some of which may not be relevant or necessary for your business. However, you’re still required to pay for these services as part of your overall fees, even if you don’t utilize them.

This lack of customization can result in you overpaying for features you don’t need, eating into your bottom line.

3. Potential for Account Holds or Termination

PayPal has a reputation for abruptly freezing seller funds or even terminating accounts with minimal warning if they consider your business high-risk. This sudden action can catch you off guard and leave you scrambling to access your money.

When PayPal deems your account high-risk, they may place a hold on your funds, restricting your ability to withdraw or use the money for an indefinite period. These holds can last for days, weeks, or even months, depending on PayPal’s assessment of the situation. During this time, you have no control over your funds, which can severely impact your cash flow and business operations.

In more extreme cases, PayPal may terminate your account entirely, often with little to no explanation. They have the sole discretion to close accounts they consider high-risk, leaving you with few options to appeal or rectify the situation. Losing access to your payment processing without warning can be crippling for your business.

4. High Transaction Fees

PayPal’s transaction fees can take a significant bite out of your profits, especially if you’re operating on slim margins or processing a high volume of sales. At 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction, these fees are among the highest in the payment processing industry.

For every sale you make through PayPal, you’ll see a substantial portion of your revenue siphoned off by these fees. If you’re selling products or services with tight profit margins, PayPal’s high transaction costs can quickly erode your earnings. The fixed $0.30 fee per transaction can be particularly burdensome for businesses that sell low-priced items, as it represents a larger percentage of the total sale amount.

As your sales volume grows, PayPal’s fees can add up to a considerable expense. The more transactions you process, the more you’ll pay in fees, which can limit your ability to scale your business profitably. For high-volume merchants, even a small difference in transaction fees can have a substantial impact on their bottom line.

Moreover, PayPal’s transaction fees are often higher than those charged by other payment processors, such as traditional merchant accounts or alternative payment gateways.

Before committing to PayPal, compare their transaction fees with those of other payment processors and assess how they align with your business model and profit margins. While PayPal’s ease of use and wide acceptance may be appealing, the high transaction fees can be a significant drawback for many merchants.

NEGOTIATE YOUR RATE WITH DIRECTPAYNET

About the author

As President of DirectPayNet, I make it my mission to help merchants find the best payment solutions for their online business, especially if they are categorized as high-risk merchants. I help setup localized payments modes and have tons of other tricks to increase sales! Prior to starting DirectPayNet, I was a Director at MANSEF Inc. (now known as MindGeek), where I led a team dedicated to managing merchant accounts for hundreds of product lines as well as customer service and secondary revenue sources. I am an avid traveler, conference speaker and love to attend any event that allows me to learn about technology. I am fascinated by anything related to digital currency especially Bitcoin and the Blockchain.