The supplement and nutraceutical industries are goldmines for both new and established business owners.

However, many business owners struggle to understand the differences between these product categories. Confusion like this can lead to serious compliance issues, marketing missteps, and payment processing challenges that hurt your bottom line.

Whether you’re launching a new vitamin line or developing a functional food product, understanding these distinctions will help you navigate regulations, choose the right marketing approach, and set up proper payment processing for your business.

OPEN A DEDICATED MERCHANT ACCOUNT

The Core Differences Between Nutraceuticals and Supplements

Nutraceuticals combine nutrition and pharmaceutical concepts to describe products that provide health benefits beyond basic nutrition. The term, coined by Stephen DeFelice in 1989, encompasses products derived from food sources that offer extra health benefits in addition to their basic nutritional value.

Supplements, on the other hand, have a specific legal definition under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994. The FDA defines them as products intended for ingestion that contain dietary ingredients meant to supplement the diet. These ingredients include vitamins, minerals, herbs, amino acids, enzymes, and other substances.

The key distinction between the two is in their primary purpose and composition. Supplements focus on filling nutritional gaps in your diet, while nutraceuticals contain bioactive compounds that target specific health concerns beyond basic nutrition.

PAYMENT PROCESSING THAT BACKS YOUR PRODUCT

Product Classification: Which Category Fits Your Business?

Determining whether your product qualifies as a supplement or nutraceutical affects everything from labeling requirements to marketing claims. Here’s how to classify your products correctly.

Your product likely qualifies as a dietary supplement if it:

• Contains vitamins, minerals, herbs, amino acids, or enzymes
• Comes in pill, tablet, capsule, powder, or liquid form
• Includes “dietary supplement” on the label
• Aims to supplement normal dietary intake
• Makes structure/function claims rather than disease claims

Your product falls into the nutraceutical category if it:

• Contains bioactive compounds beyond basic nutrients
• Targets specific health conditions or biological processes
• Provides therapeutic effects backed by scientific research
• Functions as a functional food with added health benefits
• Goes beyond addressing simple nutrient deficiencies

Many products blur these lines. For example, omega-3 supplements can function as both supplements (addressing nutritional gaps) and nutraceuticals (providing cardiovascular benefits through bioactive compounds). So which category should the product fall in? The answer depends on how you want to market it and your customer base.

SUPPLEMENT AND NUTRACEUTICAL MERCHANT ACCOUNTS

Regulatory Landscape and Compliance Requirements

The FDA regulates both categories differently, and understanding these distinctions protects your business from costly violations.

Supplement Regulations

Dietary supplements operate under DSHEA, which places the responsibility for safety and labeling on manufacturers. The FDA doesn’t approve supplements before they reach the market, but companies must follow current good manufacturing practices (cGMPs) and register their facilities.

Key compliance requirements include:

• Facility registration with the FDA
• Following cGMP standards during manufacturing
• Proper labeling with Supplement Facts panels
• Including required disclaimers about FDA evaluation
• Submitting New Dietary Ingredient (NDI) notifications for novel ingredients

Nutraceutical Regulations

Nutraceuticals face more complex regulatory oversight because they often make health claims that approach drug territory. The FDA considers nutraceuticals as a subset of foods, but products making disease claims may require drug approval.

Your nutraceutical business must navigate:

• Stricter labeling requirements for health claims
• Potential drug classification for disease treatment claims
• International regulatory variations for global markets
• Enhanced safety documentation for bioactive ingredients

KEEP YOUR BUSINESS COMPLIANT

Marketing Strategies and Claim Limitations

Your product classification directly impacts how you can market to customers and what claims you can make.

Supplement Marketing Guidelines

Supplement companies can make structure/function claims that describe how the product affects normal body functions or structure. You can say your vitamin D supplement “supports bone health” but cannot claim it “treats osteoporosis.”

Effective supplement marketing focuses on:

• Supporting normal bodily functions
• Maintaining health and wellness
• Addressing nutritional deficiencies
• Enhancing athletic performance or energy levels

All supplement marketing must include the FDA disclaimer: “These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease”.

Nutraceutical Marketing Approaches

Nutraceuticals can often make stronger health claims because they contain bioactive compounds with research-backed benefits. However, you must avoid crossing into drug territory by claiming to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent diseases.

Successful nutraceutical marketing emphasizes:

• Scientific research supporting bioactive ingredients
• Specific health benefits beyond basic nutrition
• Targeted wellness outcomes
• Prevention and risk reduction (when properly substantiated)

Always work with regulatory experts to ensure your marketing claims comply with FDA guidelines and avoid triggering drug classification.

AVOID BUSINESS SHUTDOWNS

Payment Processing Challenges and Solutions

Both supplements and nutraceuticals face payment processing challenges because financial institutions consider them high-risk industries.

Why These Industries Are High-Risk

Payment processors classify supplement and nutraceutical businesses as high-risk due to:

• Higher chargeback rates from customer expectations
• Regulatory scrutiny and compliance requirements
• Subscription billing models common in the industry
• International shipping and regulatory variations
• Potential for unsubstantiated health claims

Choosing the Right Payment Processor

Standard payment aggregators like Stripe, PayPal, or Square often shut down supplement and nutraceutical accounts without warning. These platforms use shared merchant accounts that can’t handle the unique risks of your industry.

Your business needs a dedicated high-risk merchant account that offers:

• Specialized underwriting for supplement businesses
• Higher chargeback thresholds
• Fraud protection tools designed for your industry
• Subscription billing capabilities
• International payment processing options

Work with processors experienced in nutraceutical and supplement payment processing to avoid account shutdowns and frozen funds.

OPEN A HIGH-RISK ACCOUNT WITH DIRECTPAYNET

Merchant Category Code Selection

Proper Merchant Category Code (MCC) selection can make payment processing so much smoother as well as help you avoid compliance issues with card networks.

MCC 5122: Drugs, Proprietaries, and Sundries

Most supplement and nutraceutical businesses fall under MCC 5122, which covers businesses engaged in wholesale distribution of pharmaceuticals, health and beauty aids, and related sundries.

This code applies to:

• Retail pharmacies and drugstores
• Online supplement retailers
• Businesses selling over-the-counter health products
• Merchants selling health-related sundries

Alternative MCC Options

Depending on your specific business model, you might qualify for other MCCs:

• MCC 5499 (Miscellaneous Food Stores) for functional foods
• MCC 5912 (Drug Stores and Pharmacies) for pharmacy-style operations
• MCC 5947 (Gift, Novelty, and Souvenir Shops) for specialty wellness products

Your payment processor will help determine the most appropriate MCC based on your product mix and business model.

DIRECTPAYNET CAN HELP SELECT THE RIGHT MCC FOR YOUR BUSINESS

Setting Up Your Payment Infrastructure

Successful supplement and nutraceutical businesses need robust payment infrastructure that handles their unique requirements.

Essential Payment Features

Your payment system should include:

• Recurring billing for subscription products
• International payment processing capabilities
• Advanced fraud detection and prevention
• Chargeback management tools
• Integration with popular e-commerce platforms
• Mobile payment options for in-person sales

Compliance and Security Requirements

Ensure your payment infrastructure meets:

• PCI DSS compliance standards
• 3D Secure authentication for fraud prevention
• Tokenization and encryption for data protection
• Regular security audits and monitoring
• Proper data handling for customer information

CONNECT WITH A SECURE PAYMENT PROCESSOR NOW

Best Practices for Long-Term Success

Building a sustainable supplement or nutraceutical business requires attention to both regulatory compliance and payment processing stability.

Regulatory Best Practices

• Work with experienced regulatory consultants
• Maintain detailed documentation for all health claims
• Regularly review and update product labeling
• Stay current with FDA guidance and industry changes
• Implement quality control systems throughout manufacturing

Payment Processing Best Practices

• Choose processors with supplement industry experience
• Maintain low chargeback ratios through clear marketing
• Implement strong customer service to prevent disputes
• Use fraud prevention tools to protect your business
• Monitor payment processing metrics regularly

Understanding the differences between nutraceuticals and supplements helps you make better decisions about product development, marketing strategies, and business operations.

Whether you’re selling basic vitamins or advanced functional foods, proper classification and compliance protect your business while enabling sustainable growth.

Aim to work with experienced partners who understand your industry’s unique challenges. From regulatory consultants to specialized payment processors, the right team helps you navigate complex requirements while focusing on what matters most: growing your business and serving your customers.

APPLY FOR YOUR MERCHANT ACCOUNT TODAY