Fraud hits businesses hard every year, costing companies billions in lost revenue and damaged reputations.

If you use Square Payments, I’ve got you covered. You need a solid fraud prevention strategy that protects your business without losing sales. Let’s dive into the top five proven methods that will help you build a fortress around your revenue.

APPLY FOR A REAL MERCHANT ACCOUNT

Square-Specific Fraud Prevention Tools

Square gives you powerful built-in tools to fight fraud before it happens. These features work behind the scenes to protect your business from suspicious transactions—and they’re easier to use than you might think.

Use Square’s Risk Manager and Fraud Analysis Tools

Square’s fraud analysis system automatically evaluates every transaction for potential red flags. Here’s what it does for you:

• Risk scoring: The platform assigns each order a risk level—low, medium, or high—based on multiple fraud indicators
• Visual warnings: You’ll see warning symbols next to medium and high-risk orders on your orders page
• Investigation time: This gives you the chance to dig deeper before fulfilling suspicious orders

The Risk Manager tool takes this protection even further. You can set up automated rules to block suspicious orders or require additional verification.

What makes this really powerful? Square combines machine learning, human expertise, and their massive transaction database to spot emerging fraud strategies. Your business benefits from patterns Square discovers across their entire network of millions of merchants.

Enable 3D Secure Authentication and Smart Payment Limits

Square automatically enables 3D Secure authentication, which adds an extra verification layer that fraudsters hate. Here’s how it works:

• Customer redirect: When customers make purchases, the system sends them to their card issuer’s domain for identity verification
• Liability shift: This process moves responsibility for fraudulent chargebacks from you to the card issuer
• Seamless experience: Legitimate customers barely notice the extra step

Square also implements smart payment limits as a protective measure. While these might seem restrictive at first, they actually protect your business from excessive chargebacks that could damage your merchant account. Square applies limits based on factors like new merchant status, high dispute rates, or erratic processing activity.

LOWER YOUR RISK OF FRAUD

General Fraud Prevention Strategies

Beyond Square’s built-in tools, you should implement broader fraud prevention measures that work across all aspects of your business. These strategies give you even more control over who gets through your defenses.

Collect and Verify Additional Customer Data

Smart data collection creates multiple verification points that fraudsters struggle to fake. Think of each data point as another lock on your door—the more you have, the safer you are.

Essential verification steps:

• ZIP code matching: Compare the billing ZIP code to the credit card’s registered address
• Reasonable explanations: If addresses don’t match, ask customers to explain why
• Government ID: For higher-value transactions, request identification to verify the buyer’s identity
• Never store sensitive data: Don’t keep credit card numbers on any system—this violates security standards and creates liability; tokenize instead

For online transactions, implement address verification systems (AVS) and require card security codes (CVV). These tools add authentication layers that make it much harder for fraudsters to complete unauthorized purchases using stolen card information.

Monitor Transaction Patterns and Velocity

Fraudsters often reveal themselves through their behavior patterns. They’re usually in a hurry and don’t act like normal customers. Here’s what to watch for:

Red flag behaviors:

• Multiple rapid transactions: Several purchases in quick succession from the same customer
• Unusual order sizes: Orders that are significantly larger than your typical sale
• Geographic inconsistencies: Shipping addresses that don’t make sense with billing information
• Off-hours activity: Transactions happening at unusual times for your business

Set up alerts for transactions that exceed certain thresholds or show suspicious patterns. Many payment processors, including Square, offer velocity checking that automatically flags customers making too many transactions too quickly.

Seasonal awareness matters too. Fraudsters often ramp up activity during holidays when businesses are busier and less likely to scrutinize individual transactions carefully.

Implement Multi-Factor Authentication and Device Fingerprinting

Modern fraud prevention goes beyond just checking credit cards—it looks at the entire digital footprint of each transaction.

Device fingerprinting tracks:

• Browser information: Type, version, and settings
• IP address patterns: Location and consistency over time
• Device characteristics: Screen resolution, time zone, and installed plugins

This creates a unique “fingerprint” for each customer’s device. When someone tries to use a stolen credit card from a completely different device or location, the system flags it immediately.

Multi-factor authentication adds another security layer by requiring customers to verify their identity through multiple channels. This might include:

• SMS verification codes sent to registered phone numbers
• Email confirmations for high-value purchases
• Biometric verification on mobile devices
• Security questions for account access

The beauty of these systems? They’re mostly invisible to legitimate customers but create major headaches for fraudsters trying to use stolen information.

SET UP FRAUD ALERTS

Best Practices for All Payment Types

Regardless of how customers pay, follow these universal fraud prevention practices that have stood the test of time:

• Never wire money or send funds to third parties at customer requests
• Don’t accept credit cards for services outside your normal business scope
• Use certified delivery services like UPS or FedEx—avoid sketchy shipping requests
• Avoid payment splitting: Large orders broken into multiple small payments often signal fraud; offer installment plans instead

OFFER WHITE-LABEL BNPL AT CHECKOUT

Responding to Square’s Fraud Notifications

Square monitors transactions in real-time and will alert you via email about suspicious activity. When you get these alerts, here’s your action plan:

• Don’t ship investigated orders until Square completes their review
• Avoid accepting additional payments from flagged customers during the review period
• Expect resolution within one business day, followed by a detailed follow-up email

For suspicious account activity, Square sends SMS notifications to your registered phone number. Contact Square immediately when you receive these messages—don’t wait.

LOWER YOUR FRAUD SCORE

Building Long-Term Protection

Fraud prevention isn’t a “set it and forget it” situation. It requires ongoing attention and regular updates to stay ahead of increasingly sophisticated fraudsters.

Monthly tasks:

• Review fraud alerts and patterns from the previous month
• Update any security settings based on new threats
• Check for software updates on your payment processing systems

Quarterly reviews:

• Analyze your chargeback rates and dispute patterns
• Evaluate the effectiveness of your current fraud prevention measures
• Consider working with fraud prevention professionals for policy analysis

Remember that fraud prevention balances security with customer experience. While you need strong protections, overly restrictive measures can frustrate legitimate customers and hurt sales. Use Square’s tools strategically, stay alert to emerging threats, and maintain vigilant oversight of your payment processes.

By implementing these five fraud prevention methods, you create multiple layers of protection that make your business a much harder target for fraudsters while keeping things smooth for legitimate customers. Start with Square’s built-in tools, then add the general strategies that fit your business model and risk tolerance. Your bottom line will thank you.

CONNECT WITH A MORE SECURE GATEWAY